Carphone Warehouse ( Talk Talk) seems to be coming out as favourite to buy Tiscali's UK broadband business. If this deal was to go through, it would be a significant step for Carphone Warehouse as it would acquire an IPTV business and the right to call itself the biggest broadband service provider in the UK.
Comment: Ovum does not normally comment on rumours and mere industry speculation. Indeed, this deal could never get off the ground as, according to reports, Carphone Warehouse is only interested in Tiscali's UK broadband business, and Tiscali has stated it is not interested in splitting its business up. However, we felt this one was worth commenting on given the importance of such a development if it were to go ahead.
Acquiring Tiscali's UK business would make Carphone Warehouse the biggest broadband service provider in the UK, leapfrogging both Virgin Media and BT (the UK incumbent operator). Not a bad feat given that Carphone Warehouse didn't launch its broadband business until 2006. However, this will not be the only reason for Carphone Warehouse's interest. In August 2006 Tiscali acquired Homechoice, a small but innovative IPTV player. For sometime Carphone Warehouse has been wondering what to do about IPTV, and if it was to launch how it should go about it. Although not an instant solution, much work around marketing, brand, and content strategy would still need to be done, buying Tiscali would certainly provide it with an IPTV platform and technical expertise.
As for Tiscali, if it decides that selling is the best option, it may have little choice but to split up the business as the number of potential suitors wishing to take on both the UK and Italian parts of the business is likely to be limited. It may seek a premium to do this, but at the end of the day Carphone Warehouse and other potential suitors will only be prepared to pay so much - so it may be a case of like it or lump it.
For the UK market as a whole, losing Tiscali would be a shame. Although perhaps not as exciting and dynamic as some of the other big players, it has maintained good value and simple consumer offerings, which UK consumers have come to appreciate. Over the past couple of years Tiscali has been one of the few players to see continued organic growth of its subscriber base and market share. Assuming it gets bought up by one of the other big four players, this will put 85% of the UK broadband market in the control of just four providers: BT, Virgin, Carphone Warehouse ( Talk Talk) and Sky.
Of course there are other potential buyers stalking Tiscali, with the names of Vodafone and Orange getting mentioned now and then as possibilities.
Site AdminJoined: 07 Apr 2006Posts: 784Location: United Kingdom
Tiscali’s decision to prepare itself for sale, announced this week, has shaken up the UK broadband industry at a crucial time for the sector. As the market slows – the growth rate stands at 18.5 per cent year on year compared with almost 50 per cent four years ago – and it becomes increasingly difficult to attract new consumers, the chance to grab Tiscali’s 1.7 million UK broadband customers has got the big players eyeing the group.
The trend in the broadband market, like mobile before it, is towards consolidation, with smaller players being mopped up by the big names. Analysts predict that BT, Virgin Media, Carphone Warehouse and Sky will be the survivors.
Tiscali, far from being a minnow, is the fourth-biggest broadband provider in the UK.
Analysts consider Carphone Warehouse one of the most likely buyers, although only if the price is low enough. The Acton-based group has traditionally grown its base through acquisition, snapping up AOL at the end of December 2006 for £370 million. Buying out Tiscali could prove particularly attractive as Carphone Warehouse has the chance to turn a loss-making proposition into a profitable one.
The Italian firm currently offers broadband rates of £6.49 for the first Three months and £12.49 thereafter. But given that it still has to pay line rental to BT, Tiscali is making a loss on the deal. Carphone Warehouse on the other hand has its own networks and so can offer lower prices without having to pay a proportion over to the fixed-line giant. What’s more, with Tiscali's customers under its roof, Carphone Warehouse would emerge as the market leader, pipping BT's 4.25 million customers by about 500,000.
However, integrating Tiscali's notoriously messy networks would certainly be a challenge. In the past few years it has swallowed a series of smaller companies including Pipex (which in turn had bought Bulldog), leaving it with seven different platforms and bill structures.
BT, while perhaps less likely as a suitor, also stands to gain from a putative acquisition. The company has strong organic growth – ratcheting up an additional one million customers in the past year – but gaining Tiscali's customer base would significantly expand its lead in the market. In addition, BT would obviously not incur any line charges.
However, a key consideration is the potential trouble that BT could face from regulators if it makes any major acquisitions.
Another possible contender, BSkyB, would gain from the acquisition by having access to a whole new potential subscriber base to sign up for its television package. It is becoming increasingly difficult to make money from broadband, with the service becoming increasingly commoditised as it is added to TV and mobile bundles at reduced rates or offered virtually free. Rather than a money-spinner, for a company like BSkyB it is becoming a retention tool – if customers get TV, broadband and phone line together they are less likely to stray to a rival. BSkyB has become one of the top-five internet service providers in the past year, with its customer base soaring from 232,000 to 1.2 million, elbowing old-timer Orange into sixth position. Thanks to its strong organic growth it does not have the same need to expand through acquisition.
There is still everything to play for. Tiscali has merely announced its bankers – JPMorgan Chase and Intesa Sanpaolo’s Banca IMI – but it has yet to give an indication of a timeframe for the sale. Analysts have given a wide range of estimates for the potential bid price – from £450 million to £650 million. The current share value, although slipping 3.6 per cent yesterday, reflects the strategic value of it being sold to a competitor. The share price is likely to remain skittish until the situation clarifies.
Carphone Warehouse is looking strong. It is growing fast and after two years of investing in its broadband business, analysts expect to see cashflow finally coming through when its full numbers are released in June.
Investors need to question whether they are comfortable with the company’s debt levels if it chose to go ahead with another acquisition. Market feeling is that a deal is doable, but in the current economic climate increased debt may make some investors nervous.
For very different reasons BT is also a buy. Its share price has been hit hard in the past few months yet it is trading at 9.3 times price earnings ratio, with a 7.5 per cent dividend yield. Unlike Carphone Warehouse it has low growth but it remains interesting with improvement in its global services margin due in the fourth quarter and share buybacks likely to be increased.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
